This site is part of an affiliate sales network and receives compensation for sending traffic to partner sites, such as CreditCards.com. This compensation may impact how and where links appear on this site. This site does not include all financial companies or all available financial offers. What is written in the article is the editor's opinion.
Citi’s been hit-or-miss with peeps calling in about various website errors recently.
Doctor of Credit shared an experience about getting a 5,000 bonus Citi ThankYou points because the Citi Prestige application site showed an error on earning 3X ThankYou points on all travel purchases including gas.
It actually earns 3X points on airfare and hotel purchases, not travel broadly defined – probably my only complaint on this otherwise incredible card. (Here’s how much I’ve saved I picked up the card in November 2015. And it’s available via my links if you decide to apply.)
How I got 10K points
I noticed an error at ThankYou.com. I can’t find the screenshot, but the site advertised 2,000 Hilton points for every 1,000 Citi ThankYou points. It was an artifact from a transfer bonus promotion Citi had going on, which ended January 6th, 2016.
When I clicked “Transfer”, I saw the normal 1.5:1 ratio instead.
So I called Citi and told them what I saw on my account. The rep logged in and saw the same 2:1 price, and then the lower amount after clicking through.
I told her I was hoping to get 100K Hilton points for transferring 50K Citi ThankYou points. But now I’d only get 75K.
I was transferred twice. But everything went fast. The whole call took less than 15 minutes. I spoke with a supervisor, who’d already been informed of the situation before we were connected (I love that!).
She instantly offered to split the difference and post 10K ThankYou points to my account so I’d have enough to make 100K Hilton points.
I accepted, and before I hung up, got this email:
Then I logged into my account and saw the transaction and new points balance:
I was blown away by the service and speed.
For 15 minutes on the phone, I got 10,000 Citi ThankYou points worth:
- $100 in cash
- $160 on American Airlines flights
- $133 toward other flights
- $200 with transfer partners (read how I came up with this number) Update: After all that, the points won’t transfer to TY transfer partners. HT to pointer for alerting me.
Not a bad haul!
If you wanna try
After you log in to your ThankYou.com account, click “Travel,” then “Points Transfer.”
One of the reps I spoke to said not everyone’s account has been updated yet with the correct totals. So you can see what your account says.
If you see the 2:1 rate, you can call to report it. Who knows, it’s worth a shot.
Citi ThankYou is quickly becoming my favorite points program.
The second they add a meaningful (meaning large domestic airline) transfer partner, I’ll seriously consider focusing on collecting Citi ThankYou points over Chase Ultimate Rewards points.
There are still a few glaring omissions.
For example, there’s no ThankYou shopping portal whereas the Shop Through Chase portal is very good for earning Chase Ultimate Rewards points from online shopping.
And bonus Citi ThankYou points are limited to airfare, hotels, dining, and entertainment with Citi Prestige and Citi ThankYou Premier. Although you can earn 3X Citi ThankYou points with the AT&T Access More card for most online shopping, including Amazon, which is great.
There’s still no way to earn bonus points for office supplies, drugstores, cable, etc. So that means a set number of ways to earn more than 1X ThankYou point per $1 spent. And at most, 3X bonus points.
Finally, the weird expiration and transfer rules between all the different kinds of ThankYou points is confusing. Chase doesn’t do that when you combine your points – they all never expire no matter which card you earned them with, or who you transfer them to.
And one last thing. I was hoping Citi Smart Savings would be a viable contender to compete with AMEX Offers. They rolled it out right before Black Friday, which was promising. But then it just… wasn’t that great.
However, they are making huge strides. And the service I received over this error was incredible. The only thing you can never buy back from a customer is bad will. Take notes, AMEX!
Let me know if you have luck getting extra ThankYou points!
BEST Current Credit Card Deals
- Chase Sapphire Reserve - 50,000 Ultimate Rewards points - My review of this card.
- Discover it® Cashback Match™ Card - $50 after 1st purchase within 3 months of account opening - Why I love this card!
- Hilton Surpass Amex - 85,000 Hilton points - Why I picked up this card.
- Chase Hyatt card - 40,000 Hyatt points and a free night at a Category 1 through 4 hotel each year on your cardmember anniversary - Here are 5 great hotels to redeem your free night!