Why I Don’t Care About SPG Starpoints

This site is part of an affiliate sales network and receives compensation for sending traffic to partner sites, such as CreditCards.com. This compensation may impact how and where links appear on this site. This site does not include all financial companies or all available financial offers.

Don't give a!

Don’t give a!

I fully admit I’m a rookie at best with miles and points collecting, but I’ve never understood the allure of Starpoints.

In theory, they are like a rare, valuable currency that can get one access to a variety of different airlines and hotel locations. But in practice, are they worth it?

Starcrap

The best signup bonus I’ve ever seen for the SPG Card is 30,000 Starpoints, which translates to 35,000 miles of a whole lot of different airlines. The signup bonus is great, and so is the flexibility. But there are a couple of things about the card that have also irked me.

  • After you get the initial 30K, then what? The card has a fixed 1:1 earning structure, except at Starwood hotels. Starwood hotels is a very small category. Even if you were Gold with them and spent $10,000, you’d only get 30K Starpoints for that spend
  • I get it. Starpoints haven’t suffered as much as inflation as say, Hilton HHonors points. That is to say, there are fewer Starpoints in circulation, so each one is worth more. But is it? 30K miles on most airlines will get you a R/T domestic trip in economy. But those 100K+ biz class trips that the bloggers like to talk about would require tens of thousands of dollars in spend. Redeeming for rooms is way more valuable, but if you’re gonna go through the trouble, why not just get a Hilton or Hyatt card and be done with it?
  • I’m notorious for not really caring about hotels. I have had some lovely experiences at some aspirational properties like the Mandarin Oriental in London and Hilton Waikiki Village (it was aspirational to me at least). But when it’s par for the course, I’d rather rent a charming room off Airbnb or stay with friends. Also, in terms of Ultimate Rewards, if I’m going to transfer 50K UR points, it certainly won’t be for one night in a hotel room. Rather, I’d prefer to save it for a really nice flight. I guess I enjoy the journey more than the destination
  • Transfers can be either instant or slow as molasses with Starpoints transfer partners. Who can afford to hold an award booking for 2 weeks (as in the case of Singapore Airlines), or even a few days (more common)? I’m all for searching dates to see what’s available, but I always have the understanding that if I don’t snap it up right then and there, it will probably be gone when I check it again. For this reason, Starpoints seem difficult to plan an award with
  • Foreign transfer fees. Ew! I refuse to pay this ridiculous fee. So even if you have the card, it’s advisable to have another one, like the Chase Sapphire Preferred, that doesn’t have those fees associated with it. Internationally, it’s better to pay with Starwood hotels with a non-Starwood card? That just doesn’t make sense to me. So if I’m limited to the US anyway, again, I’d rather hit up friends, search Airbnb, or find a Hyatt or Hilton.

Bottom line

All that being said, I do respect the way Starwood pioneered points earning structures and transfers, and redemptions with no blackout dates. LOVE that. I just feel like times have changed since the beginning of the program, but the benefits of this card haven’t evolved to fit the current points market.

Am I alone in this? Is there something I’m totally missing here?

Editorial Note: Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, hotel, airline, or other entity. This content has not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of the entities included within the post.

* If you liked this post, consider signing up to receive free blog posts via email (only 1 per day!) or in an RSS reader and you’ll never miss an update! And thanks for using my links to apply for new card offers!

About Harlan

Just a dude living in Dallas.

More articles by Harlan »

Pingbacks

Comments

  1. The best redemption is the cash+points in the lower category, or full redemption for category 1-4. I value my Starpoints at 0.2cents/point, and I won’t redeem anything below that.

    In terms of earning, I agree 1x for purchasing is quite low, I hope they can change that.

    • If they could change the earning structure of that card, or at least make a portal or something, I’d be really into Starwood. Maybe one day!

  2. SPG Plt 100+ here w/ Amex card. It is pretty easy to bankroll a lot of SPG points. 500 platinum welcome points, 250/500 per night for make a green choice, 3x/$ Uber partnership (and uber partners with Amex for 2x MR), Delta partnership, 4 points per dollar spent, Amex 2 spg/$ on hotels, and finally the ever-frequent promos like Take Two.

    SPG is going away. But Starpoints as it stands are valued at easily 3-4c/point if you redeem at hotels. If you transfer these to KrisFlyer/FlyingBlue/etc – your realized value can approach 7-9c/point.

    Convertible currencies give me increased flexibility.

    • SPG definitely has a lot going for it (or had). Hyatt points always seemed much easier to earn thanks to Chase UR, and have similar redemption rates. Plus, Chase UR points often have a high value per point with airlines.

      I guess it really comes down to your travel goals, and how you like to travel. It sounds like you have a good thing going with SPG – keep it up while the gettin’ is still good!

      I always like to hear what peeps think about the various points systems and hotel chains. All good stuff – thank you for weighing in!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *